Countdown,
Setting aside all this brouhaha about where levels should be…. I can confirm that we’ve had the EXACT same problem with the broadcast safe filter. Even stranger, we’ve found that the editor made an adjustment to “safe”, thought he was good to go, and then discovered that the “render” reverted back to the “hot” levels. In other words, the correction was made, but the results were luminence around 108 or 110. Double clicking on the offending clip showed the levels in the correct place. It was very frustrating, and resulted in one of our shows getting kicked back.
Yes we have outboard scopes, and yes we know what we’re doing. I’ve never had a show THAT far out of specs on so many clips. So… while I agree that you SHOULD be able to go up to 100, it really is much safer to tread the waters around 90 to avoid these kind of unpleasant experiences.
Mark