What a pain.. thanks for the input guys, playing with the material settings doesn’t help much, and i’ve got many many layers here that need separate lights and shadows. Im gonna end up lighting each layer separately and faking the shadows. Sucks, but it’s taking too long to precomp each layer, each precomp would need a copy of the camera, that’s about 25 cameras to apply adjustments to..
For those who are having similar problems: I’ve found that using spots instead of point lights helps a little since it restricts the light angle. but it doesnt solve the problem completely.
AE’s lights aren’t raytracers, so i guess you cant expect too much.
From now on, when i do 3d work im gonna just stay in the 3d app….