I use Prelude a lot and I love to work alone! Get off my lawn! It’s great for exactly what you’re needing to do. I’m hardly ever at a shoot anymore, but cards/drives just get dropped off and the hunt begins. The advantages to using it for me is I create a tag template for each gig that includes camera name, composition (CU, MCU, 2 shot, etc.), Day #, Talent/Character, Broll, interior, exterior and on and on. So I ingest the shots and run through them quickly tagging them then go back and start subclipping. It’s much easier to remove unwanted camera roll with the excellent waveform display you get along with the video and marking multiple parts of a clip is a breeze. You literally hit one key to add an in and you immediately have an open description window to type in, hit enter and set the out. Done.
Sort all the clips by subclip or however you want, put them in bins, whatever. Then highlight anything you’ve created and send to PPro and it shows up just like you had it. All the media is then searchable by the tags or descriptions and those same things can be used to create smart folders in your project bin.
The big thing is it was MADE to do what you want to do. Yes, you can mark and subclip in PPro but it’s way clumsy compared to doiing it Prelude. And what you do in Prelude stays with the media unlike what happens in PPro. So down the road if you load a clip you’ve marked in Prelude into another project the markers and subclips will come along for the ride. You only have to find the best part of a clip once and it will always be there for you. Or you just return to the original Prelude project and find what you want that way. Easier than going back to a big edit project.
Thanks Alex, but I’d consider myself the resident fan!