Hi Zachary,
I’ve run into similar issues before. Make sure both monitors are properly calibrated with their ICC profiles. In After Effects, go to **Preferences > Display** to check if color management is enabled. If you don’t see the “Display Color Management” option, try resetting your preferences or updating to the latest version of After Effects. Sometimes, restarting the application can also help make the setting appear.
Hope this resolves the inconsistency!
Best,
Nir-Vana