Great reading this thread.
I agree with Tim, Adobe is going to do what it can, but certainly not please everyone. It took Photoshop 5 versions to get the text tool easy to work with.
Perfection takes a while.
My office has a Media 100i on a G3 on one desk, and Premiere Pro directly opposite, I can just about reach them both with my arms extended.
I have assigned as many keyboard commands to Premiere Pro to emulate Media 100 as possible.
Obviously PPro adds numerous great features which M100 does not have.
The few it does not have which M100 does have are seemingly obvious features for a “PRO” editor, but what are ya gonna do?
Interesting that Adobe tacked the word Pro on to their existing product, probably to verbally compete with FCP, yet not including some of the Pro features as FCP.
Not having a G5 or FCP or AE for that matter I cannot say which is better, but from what I read FCP does everything. Does it do everything well? Probably not.
Well that’s my two and a half cents. I can do things in PPro that I could not do on my M100 or certainly not on my Ampex ACE 25. However the ability to manually control the ADO with a joystick was great!
Mike