I tried unchecking “preserve aspect ratio” at 1920×1080 and that worked. I also realized that coming out of compressor I had to set the pixel aspect to square in the geometry tab. I think I understand this a little better now, and at least I’ll now what to look for if quicktimes are displaying incorrectly. In fact, I’m compressing a 1440×1080 to mp4 right now to 1280×720, and with the pixel aspect set to square i believe that should come out correctly. I did a test and it seemed right. Does that sound like the proper setting to you?
Thanks for your help!