> … when rendering an 1080p HD format from a SD project. Is there a noticeable improvement when shown on an HD monitor? /i>
Improvement? No. In fact it will probably look worse. HD has 5x the resolution of SD so imagine zooming a picture 500% in Photoshop and think about what it looks like. You will also have the 4:3 to 16:9 aspect to deal with.
I would start by making a test render to see how bad it is. Try a little sharpening in Vegas. If that doesn’t look acceptable to your client you could try buying a program that specializes in uprezing SD to HD. They do a pretty good job but it doesn’t look as good as HD (but it looks better than regular SD would).
You could also convert your SD footage to HD by exporting all of the frames as PNG’s and batch converting in Photoshop and then reassembling into HD video. (this is essentially what the uprez plug-ins do). Very tedious but could work in a pinch.
Good Luck,
~jr
http://www.johnrofrano.com
http://www.vasst.com