If this is truly an “archive” I would not modify the video in any way. I would simply transfer it to digital format in it’s existing state. If these are old VHS tapes you might want to upgrade to a Canopus ADVC-300 because it has built-in time-based correction (TBC) and filters for cleaning up bad signals on the way in.
I would not use Neat Video or Instant HD on the archived footage. Here’s why: just 5 years ago, we didn’t have video cleaners like Neat Video. You may have used some 2D or 3D noise cleaners from VirtualDub and they may have done a pretty good job. 5 years later, Neat Video comes along and it can do a better job but you don’t have the original source anymore. You now have a modified / cleaned up source that doesn’t have the original noise to process. You have forever sealed the quality of that footage to the clean-up that was done 5 years ago. What about 5 years from now? There will be tools that are better than Neat Video. If you alter the “archive” now you will not be able to use new tools in the future to get a better result later.
If I were you, I would save the unaltered source as an archive and then if you want to clean it up with Neat Video or any other tool, you do that as a separate project that doesn’t alter the source. This gives you the option of going back 5 years from now and doing an even better job.
~jr
http://www.johnrofrano.com
http://www.vasst.com