> I’ve never encountered such compatability issues before when it comes to conversion – is this just because HD / AVC is fairly new ?
I’m not sure if it’s the newness or the unwillingness to support a standard. AVCHD is the standard and consumers should look for a standard solution but it’s tough when the AVCHD camera costs $500 and the MPEG4 camera costs $99.
> I spoke to the purchaser of the camera and they showed me articles which they read when choosing it which showed MTS as a poorly supported format
Well it certainly isn’t poorer that an unsupported MP4 format. 😉 They may have misinterpreted what they read. Even a poorly supported standard is still a standard and still has a better chance of interoperability than rolling your own MP4 file that no one supports.
> and they assumed MP4 (supported by Apple et al) as an obvious choice.
Unless you are using a Mac, it doesn’t matter what Apple does or doesn’t support (Besides, I thought Apple didn’t like anything that wasn’t a MOV file). MP4 has several profiles and not all software and cameras support all profiles so it causes a lot of problems.
> Back to my original message, I could really do with a simple, cost effective batch convertor for HD (AVC) encoded MP4’s. Does anyone know of such a thing ?
Have you tried VASST GearShift? It will happily convert all of your MP4 files to Sony YUV or CineForm AVI which edits beautifully in Vegas. This is a specialized version of what is in Ultimate S Pro (and costs a lot less) 😉
~jr
http://www.johnrofrano.com
http://www.vasst.com