First off a simple man asking a simple question.
Not to derail this topic but I figured to ask here since I feel its the best place to add (and not to start a new topic).
My question is more “chicken or the egg” as far as editing processes go.
An argument I’ve had many at times with different colleagues.
If one is to do a commercial spot (an example), what’re your thoughts if a client picked a music bed first?
I’ve had arguments on this one where one editor would ignore the music bed all together until the end.
Of course, I would reply with the music video process where one is to edit to a specific music track provided.
This topic on my end has come up in so many levels from feature/short films, docs, and tv spots.
Should an editor be so biased as to how to start a process?
What if the client is adamant that the music should be the basis of the edits?
I want to say “to each his/her own” but I also instruct NLE software at local college and would like to have some input from this fabulous forum ☺
Please go easy on me, I’m asking since it’s been burning in my head for years now.