Only things I could think of in favor of the Avid:
– it might be somewhat more stable/reliable (ONLY talking about the app, not the platform), especially in terms of media management (think of all the issues folks have with the MediaManagler in FCP trying to redigz seq’s with speed changes, nests, etc.). That being said, FCP5 is *supposed* to have addressed the MediaMangler problems. In an HD environment, with renewed emphasis on offline/online workflow, this could be a pain if MM isn’t fixed on FCP5. Also, being a turnkey NLE from one company (via VARs), with established support vendors (pro facility maintainance shops), makes serious issues perhaps more easily fixed.
– Adrenaline has a rez-independent timeline, at least DV/SD – I do NOT know if this extends to HD.
– Avid Unity. if you need it, there’s nothing comparable for FCP.
– having cut on everything from CMX to Quantel to Avid to FCP, give me FCP. (well, OK, give me a Quantel iQ/eQ if I don’t have to PAY for it!).
Bob Woodhead / Atlanta
Quantel-Avid-FCP-3D-Crayola
G5 DP 2G, 10.3.4, 3.5GB RAM, FCP 4.5, Aja IO, Huge 320R [raid3]