Hi Mike,
I don’t think it is a fair assesment at all, the HDV cameras are not in the same league as far as features and are roughly equivalent in resolution. I shoot the hvx with an M2 adapter and I don’t think anything comes close to that combination if you are looking for a film look unless you spend $75K or more ! For me it works for you it may not; don’t take anyones word for it…check it out yourself.
Aloha
-A