Hello Ben,
I’ve been through the “can’t get it out of the box at 16:9” syndrome. That’s a little different than what’s going on here. At least I think it is. For me the answer to that was to use a 16:9 anamorphic setting in the advanced export folder in Compressor. A guy here locally showed me that one. Since then, things have been better.
Among other things, don’t get caught up in what the capture window is showing you during capture, I don’t think the capture window knows what to do with 16:9 (at least from my machine) but it doesn’t seem to matter once I get the video in.
My problem was that half of my clips on canvas were fine and the other half weren’t and I don’t think I changed anything.
I remember someone talking about some sort of digital flag or data marker recorded and generated by a camera that needed to be recognized for 16:9 to show properly. The string I read seemed to say that some cameras didn’t have the ability to generate the proper data to tell FCP that the video was 16:9. I don’t know how fragile that flag is, or how cavalier FCP may be with it. If that’s not it, someone please correct me.
For these current clips, I used the output setting in Compressor suggested by Ken Stone for how to make your clips for YouTube. Wow, I never knew there were so many settings. Has Apple made FCP infinitely adjustable to its own detriment? These settings, btw, preserved the 16:9. You can see them, if you like at https://idisk.mac.com/tyreeford-Public
They are in a folder called “GuitarsOfPikesville.”
Hope this has been of some help.
Finally, I’ve been producing audio for years. Does anyone else have problems with the way audio is handled in FCP or Soundtrack Pro? Is it just me? Seems like the GUI was created by people who never operated pro audio gear.
Regards,
Ty Ford
Want better production audio?: Ty Ford’s Audio Bootcamp Field Guide
Watch Ty play guitar