Timothy Auld
Forum Replies Created
-
Ok, what are you talking about? What delivery systems require tracks? All of them from my perspective. Some require one thing and another on this track or that but they all require that specific audio be placed on specific tracks. Is this outside of your experience?
Tim
-
Really Andy. Are you kidding me? Tracks? Who needs those in the real world?
Tim
-
And to finally put this to bed (he says like anyone will listen) You can do ANYTHING in X that you can do in 7 or Avid or Premiere CC (execpt for multi cam in CC) that you can do in any NLE. The problem here is that Apple thinks they are driving the post production debate, And from my perspective they should just give up. Someone tell me who is delivering anything (and yes I”ll take crocodile or housewife stuff) started and finished on FCP X. Anyone? Bueller?
Tim
-
Yes. Finally. If you need tracks – whether you want them or not – then FCPX is not for you. I NEED TRACKS. To conform with any number of delivery systems. Jesus Hairy Christ! Who, that delivers programming in the real world, does not see this?
Tim
-
Quite true. I worked on something shot entirely with Epic last year and it hit theater screens at 1080p, as do most movies these days.
Tim
-
Certainly I’m already seeing it used in production fairly regularly. As far as consumer TV’s, I don’t know.
The first time I saw HD was at NAB in 1986. And it still a given everywhere in the market.Tim
-
Different cards have limitations on the size of the display. I’d check that first, if you haven’t already.
Tim
-
Yes, without question, we disagree about that.
Tim
-
Stereo is a phasing illusion. I need mono tracks. Until I’m ready for them to be otherwise. Also, I need to easily be able to layer audio. And in X it just ain’t easy.
Tim
-
If that’s the way it works for you then great. It would not be easier for me.
Tim