Yeah so Im sorry if this is turning into an argument and I dont wish to cause offence either but do editors also not understand jokes these days?
Im fully aware that there is no ‘plugin of awesomeness’, and the ‘basic’ questions I have asked are purely to expand my knowledge. My tutor when I was at University told me it’s irrelevant how much technical knowledge you have, as long as you can cut together a good story with timing (she’s an ex ITV by the way). I’ve been editing for over 8 years, but have taught myself most of what I know.
There is also another editor of some huge programmes, which I wont mention for fear of implications, who says I have more “technical” knowledge than him, but he’s obviously a better editor, because he’s had about 20 years more experience than me.
The questions Ive asked here are only the GAPS in my knowledge, which I only have because of lack of teaching…. rather than lack of skill or time spent editing… you could spend 50 years in front of Final Cut Pro and not know the specifics of what 4.2.2 actually MEANS, or what the difference between square and rectangular pixels means in terms of how it displays in various programmes, but by god they’d be a good story creator.
Furthermore, a BBC commission was just won here by a guy who edited his own piece, and he has little or no technical knowledge, the timing was just perfect.
So it could be argued that by using ‘technical knowledge’ as a benchmark for me being a bad editor, you could be insinuating the same about yourself…. People at Apple probably have more technical knowledge than me about elements of FCP etc. An IT technician I know could probably answer many of the questions Ive asked here. But can I edit better than him?….yes.
I know it takes hard work.
Anyway, sorry if Ive taken anything out of context, but I felt the last comment was pointless, was not constructive and doesn’t really help anything, on a forum which is supposed to be about help rather than lecturing…
If I HAVE taken it all the wrong way, and you were trying to offer friendly advice, then I apologise.
😀
Tom Morter-Laing
Certified Apple Product Proffessional, 2010
Degree; TV Production
iMac 27″ intel i7 2.93GHz, 12GB RAM, ATI HD5750 [1GB GDDR5], 2TB Int. SATA with 2TB External HDD; (FW800).