Do I have this right?
So you shot at 60fps, edited at 60fps, slow-mo clips were at 60fps, and delivery is 24fps?
Ideally you’d have shot the majority of your work at 24fps, edited at 24fps, clips you’d like to slow-mo would’ve been shot at 60fps (and then conformed to 24fps using Cinema Tools, creating a smooth and seamless slowmo – know as over cranking), and then your delivery would be at 24fps.
In your question, you’re going to take 60fps and attempt to reduce it to 24fps. Depending on what/how you shot this will have varying levels of success. I don’t know that either way you listed is better than the other. Likely just try them both and see what results you get. Which I think is what my colleague is saying with his post: [Steve Eisen] “Wrong workflow!”
If you want to see what 24fps looks like, then shoot your events at 24fps.
Ryan Holmes
http://www.ryanholmes.me
@CutColorPost