[beenyweenies] “I should also note that in a recent interview one of Adobe’s own product guys conceded that AE’s compressed output was not up to snuff.”
If that’s the case, then rendering to ALL compressed formats from AE should be objected to. That is obviously not what this Adobe guy meant. Hence, that is not what we shold be regurgitating.
Not having listened to the original discourse, I would nonetheless suss it out that the topic in question, then, was compressing movies for the Web and not compression in general, which includes the Animation CODEC, Motion JPEGs, etc. Having said that, WMV output from AE is pretty acceptable. No 2-pass VBR and fancy filters but it does a good job for client previews over the Web – good-sized file and pretty good quality.
FWIW, DVD Studio Pro used to have very poor MPEG-2 encoding. It’s gotten better. I kinda like the MPEG-2 encoding in AE7. It does CBR rather well at the 7-8Mbit range. If you’re looking for VBR MPEG-2 solutions then AE will not be a suitable tool.
Best to check it out with the folks at the COW’s Compression Forum. They love this kinda stuff.
Cheers
Roland Kahlenberg
https://www.broadcastGEMs.com – AE Project Files
https://www.myspace.com/rorkrgbspace