Looks like someone is seeing the magic bullet for successful filmmaking. The trouble is that so many variables determine success. Did you hire the right talent for the script? Were the locations believable for the story? Did the Director and DP approach the script and story to make the most impact? How much did music play in setting the right emotion? All of these factors are determined by sometimes hundreds of different roles and talent. So although a script looks successful on paper, the actual success won’t be known until the final film is put in front of an audience. And sometimes even the top talent can produce a loser.
So data is important, I suppose, but budget sometimes determines what you can do with that data. For example, if I cast Tom Hanks I have a pretty good chance of a successful film, but if the budget is $150k I’m not getting Tom Hanks. How is my success impacted by budget?
On the other hand, if I have $150k with all new actors but somehow the stars align and I have the next big indy film, well, that can happen too.
Not sure a spreadsheet would guarantee success, nor would anyone put their faith in simply raw data to determine if their project will be successful. And furthermore, a passionate filmmaker would not be deterred by data alone if it suggested their project would fail.
Hmmmm.