We use Avids for editing. I work in 2:1 or 1:1, I export quicktimes using the Avid codec and then go right into compressor.
We have Compressor 2, and my settings are: 2 pass VBR, 8.5peak, 7.2 base, best motion estimation, lower fied first.
The problems I’m having are: sparkles (mpeg noise) in some dissolves. And a general lifting of the black levels and thereby a slight desaturation. I read that this is intentional from Apple due to some issues with DV (they presume that is the source). In my case we’re digitizing digi-beta film transfers or HD camera originals. Compressor is easy to use for sure, but the adjustments seem to add more noise than they’re worth. I compressed the program I was having issues with in Procoder and although it solves the sparkels in the dissolves, the overall look was harsh compared to what we’re used to seeing out of compressor. I think I’m going to give Compression Master a try next as I’d like to keep the workflow all Mac if possible.
Any comments regarding Compression Master setting is more than welcome.