Have you really tried this? I have, and no setting seems to help in AE 8bit NTSC (for HD, encoding with Off or Upper Field works fine). In a 16bit NTSC AE project, when rendering out using the BMD 10bit 4:2:2 codec field order is fine. The same progressive NTSC file sequence rendered on a PPro timeline in the NTSC 8bit 23.976 BMD preset is also fine. There seems to be something wrong with the Uncompressed 8bit AVI codec. Curiously, the same 240 frames rendered in AE 8bit uncompressed (240MB) is larger than the 10bit BMD codec (213MB). From a 8bit BMD PPro timeline the same 240 frames is 160MB. Has there ever been a time where you could select a BMD NTSC 8bit 4:2:2 codec for rendering in AE?
V-IV