Jon –
If this is the dumbest stuff you’ve heard from a film schooler then your living a charmed life.
While statements 2 and 5 reveal a certain level of ignorance and answer 3 indicates some limitations in cerebral functioning not uncommon to the young, his comments re: Blade runner and Alien just indicate that he doesn’t like the work of Riddley Scott – an opinion I tend to share – and prefers the work of James Cameron. Surely this is not an outrageous statement – I know many people who prefer Aliens to Alien.
As for Blade Runner, it was revolutionary in it’s Art Direction, it had the good sense to show the young Daryl Hannah in skin tight outfits as often as possible, and it provided Phillip Dick with some much needed money and recognition in his last year on earth. Other than that, well what can you expect from a movie that passed over the original book title “Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?” for the empty hipness of “Blade Runner.”
Herb Sevush
Zebra Productions