Mark,
I will try hard to not sound like a biased NYer and I quite understand that the 21 century might see China become the pre-eminent economic power in the world, however…
Pick a criteria: Architecture. Nope. Public Transportation. Nope. Public Cleanliness. Definitely Not. Industrial output? Not by a factor of ten. Financial power? Debatable. While all you New Yorkers were chanting “USA, USA, USA” or “We’re Number one” the center of the universe was shifting. Westward. All the way to China.
Cleanliness??? when was NY ever clean? Industrial output???? when was NY in the top 20 of industrial cities even in the US? NY’rs chanting “USA,USA” – my guess is that there is less jingoistic fervor in NY than any city in the US. Do you have NY somehow mixed up with Des Moines?
I’m sure NY’s public transport looks archaic – it is archaic. That’s because it’s been in the business of moving millions of people a day for almost one hundred years.
NY has always been about money — making it, trading it, stealing it. But because that wealth was accruing in a relatively “free” and liberal society, along with that wealth came one of the perks that come with the gold, namely culture. NY is rich in money, rich in culture – art, music, literature -and also, and most importantly, it is rich in people.
If you can re-call the video clip that started that whole thread twice the speaker remarked that it was surprising to find a cabbie who spoke English – and this got a big laugh from the audience. It got a laugh because it’s quite true – the driver could have been pakistani, indian, mexican, from any of twenty countries in Africa or a dozen countries in the mid-east. They come here for a reason, and as long as we welcome them and they still choose to come, then I don’t worry about the future of this city.
I’ve never been to Asia, obviously never been to China. When a Chinese spokesman can tell a story about a Panamanian or Nigerian or Pakistani cab driver who took him to the airport, then I might concede NYs right to considered the “center of the universe.”
Herb Sevush
Zebra Productions