First of all I do realize that we are not changing Apple’s mind here in this discussion but, there is precedence and reason for the argument. There are several companies that encourage students to make the change from academic use to commercial use by offering them something for their initial investment. For example, Alias allows you to buy an academic->commercial upgrade from the education license. It works out to be a little cheaper in total for this path actually but the main point is you get to take your initial, albeit smaller, investment and get some application out of it.
I just don’t see how it hurts Apple to do this when they get a practically guaranteed customer for future upgrades whereas they take the risk in having them go elsewhere when they graduate due to cheaper perceptively cheaper H/W and market pressure.
gl