Craig,
Your comment about lack of ergonomics (and the other comments made here) echo my own.
Apple’s implementation of audio features in FCP 7 was never that great to begin with. I think Apple is guilty of very sequestered thinking in how the FCP X development team was created. Narrow choosing is not a bad idea, necessarily, but picking the people is very important.
FCP X was a “baby and bathwater” GUI swap out. An interesting approach; throw out most of the well known controls and wait to hear who scream the loudest for what features before adding them back in. It seems like they also scraped off the entire FCP 7 team and tossed the project into the iMovie crew.
Again, not necessarily a bad thing, (yes, some will howl) but why Apple hasn’t used some of the Logic Express team on FCP X (or listen to what they have to say), keeps FCP X’s controls shrouded is mysterious. Maybe it was just money and the roll out schedule. Or, is it the famous “Generational Shift” I keep hearing about? The younger team members just don’t have the operational underpinning to appreciate how the work has been done for years.
One thing’s for sure; wanking on about it in a Cow/Apple Forum isn’t likely to change anything. I reached out to Apple years ago about the audio implementation in FCP 5 or 6. My inquiries were met with tepid response.
Regards (and “Hey” to Noah),
Ty Ford
Cow Audio Forum Leader
Want better production audio?: Ty Ford’s Audio Bootcamp Field Guide
Ty Ford Blog: Ty Ford’s Blog