[Ty Ford] “You have been told how and why your thoughts will get you in trouble.”
You know, I really don’t understand the hostility here. Your response consisted of “Don’t do it.” David’s was “It’s a horrible idea.” Where is the how or the why in either of those?
Dear Tom, There is no hostility on this end.
[Ty Ford] “Even in theory, your idea will not work. ”
See, again, you throw out a statement with no support. That’s not discussion, it’s browbeating. Why is the idea so offensive to you? The concept is to reduce ambient sound and allow for critical listening; how is this different from having sound isolation headphones, or working in a quiet environment?
No, Tom, these are facts. Rail against science if you want, but please keep me out of it.
[Ty Ford] “Please test it before the reality of it bites you it the butt and tarnishes your reputation.”
Yes, absolutely! I rely on tried-and-true methodologies. You’ll notice that I ran out and bought the amazing cans David mentioned.
I suspect that sound cancelling technology is immature, but it sure looks promising. If you were to have suggested, 20 years ago, that taking an in-line noise filter to a shoot was a good idea, you’d have been roundly scoffed. Now, it was your go-to response, and one supported by others. Why is it crazy to think that, 20 years from now, sound cancelling monitoring won’t be the norm?
Dear Tom, I don’t care. I’ll very like be dead.
[Ty Ford] “I’m not sure we can be of further assistance.”
I’m interested in discussion. Informed feedback. Maybe even someone who is experimenting with the concept. If all you’re interested in is telling me “no,” mission accomplished. Feel free to ignore my continued curiosity.
Dear Tom, if you peruse the posts, I don’t think you’ll find a lot of discussion. The main crew who hangs here, myself included, have day jobs and are not paid to hang out.
[Ty Ford] “That has been asked and answered. Please move on.”
Does it really hurt you so much to allow exploration of a valid question?
Tell you what. Report your question and open it up for discussion.
Regards,
Ty Ford
Cow Audio Forum Leader
Want better production audio?: Ty Ford\’s Audio Bootcamp Field Guide
Ty Ford Blog: Ty Ford\’s Blog