Hello Bob,
Yep, that’s the way I see it.
This is a revisitation of the nightmare I saw when the FCC first said they were going to auction off the 700MHz band because their researched showed *no one was using it. By No One they meant they had no filed registrations by users.
There was this panel at NAB one year that was to air this out. I was not on the panel but I was in the audience as a user and as a journalist. There was a member of the FCC on the panel and some of the wireless mfgrs. and/or distributors, as I recall.
I challenged the FCC guy by saying that if he simply took a look at the unit sales for wireless mics from the mfgrs in the room, it would be obvious to him that there were many times more professional users out there working everyday that the skimpy list of radio and TV stations who comprised most of his list. I reached out to him sometime later by phone only to hear he was retiring and wouldn’t have to worry about the problem. (not that I thought he was worried about it then.)
He was like so many crushed and eviscerated federal employees doing their jobs, keeping their heads down, and praying for early (and full) retirement.
You could say (and some did) that because the industry is comprised of competing mfgr companies whose job it is to outsell the others, that forming an aligned committee to front in a way that the FCC would ::sigh:: have to recognize might work, and some have tried that. Looks like the FCC are deaf to the pleas. It will probably take a more powerful organization to get their proper attention.
I’m thinking maybe kick it upstairs to the various film academies to send some big name actors to congress (Sorry, I know congress should be capitalized, but I don’t think they deserve it. I live in Baltimore and the smell from down south when the wind blows up this way from DC is never pleasant.)
Said actors would titillate the committee and there would be a big deal about how having spectrum for their work is essential. Back room deals about which actor would step out in favor of this or that politician or his/her legislation would occur and we’d get us some spectrum…..maybe.
Mfgrs will, as they have before, wait for the new terrain before deciding what to do. It wasn’t THAT long ago that wireless mics were fixed frequency. Now, because of this very issue, they are spread spectrum. Mfgrs need to roll with the punches in order to manufacture and sell gear so they stay in business, but there’s no need or reason to offer solutions when even the near term fate is uncertain.
Smoke ’em if ya got ’em! Please feel free to circulate this to anyone.
Ty Ford
Cow Audio Forum Leader
PS: I find it only slightly amusing that I’m making this statement on April 1st
Want better production audio?: Ty Ford’s Audio Bootcamp Field Guide
Ty Ford Blog: Ty Ford’s Blog