After spending too much non-productive time reading the thread above, for me it simply comes down to this; Old Fart or Yousgster-it doesn’t matter. What matters is making a living off of our business. I would say that I fall into the old fart category, chronologically but not technically. I’ve been making a living off of this industry for going on 40 years now and can still keep up with the “Kids” easily. What matters most to me is this: can the tools I have available right now enable me to make a decent living? That’s it. Simple. Can I still make a living off of Studio 3 and FCP 7 along with many other applications? Absolutely. Can I make a living using FCPX? Definitely not. It doesn’t (yet) have the functionality I require for the projects I do. Will it in the future? Possibly. Hopefully. It’s just that Apple has left a bad taste in my mouth over how they are handling the whole FCPX thing. But that’s a discussion for a different day. In the meantime I’ll be sticking with one of the reliable old “A’s” – Apple, Avid and Adobe until things shake out a bit. This will help strengthen all three in the long run, I feel. I have no problem learning and trying new methods to achieve what I need. It’s just that I also have to be able to pay the bills at the same time. I always keep a keen eye on the industry and adapt my workflow as the technology evolves, but the fact of the matter is, I won’t be a trend setter anytime soon. But I also don’t need to worry about being called a dinosaur either. Like most of us in the business we keep our eyes open to what works and what doesn’t and modify out workflow on a regular basis to keep up with trends. I tend to be cautious in jumping on anything new and shiny until I can see just how it fits into what I require for my production work. If it works and I need it, I will adapt. If not, I will pass it by. It’s not so much a matter of blaze ahead or be left behind. It’s a matter of what works for you in a given situation. Right now, FCPX doesn’t work for me. Simple. Oh, and I do have an iPad that I use as a remote control surface for some hardware boxes I use. It’s great for that and I use it all the time. But editing on an iPad? Nope, not yet. That’s not saying “never” however, just not today, thank you.
Tom
E=MC2+/-2db