Olly,
I’m just finishing my 3rd commercial DVD release that was partially shot with EX1/EX3’s in 50i mode alongside an HDcam HDW790. To date we have sold some 5000 copies of the first two releases without a single mention of any problems with the pictures, in fact we get great comments about picture quality I simply edit in FCP and make an SD Mpeg 2 file directly from the HD timeline and the results have no problems at all.
If you check my e-bay store and look at my feedback on the following titles “The Shuttleworth Collection 2008” and “Flying Legends 2008” you will see people are very happy with the results!
https://stores.ebay.co.uk/Aviation-DVD-Store
I also have some web videos here which have EX content on, I know they aren’t SD as such, but if there was a downconversion problem then it would show with Web Video as well.
https://www.vimeo.com/user542524/videos The B17 video on this site was entirely shot on the EX1
I have even made NTSC versions of the discs with no issues.
Yes, you should turn the detail down, I’m not quite sure what all the hysteria is about the EX not doing good SD. I’m more than happy with it.
Steve Connor
Adrenalin Television
Have you tried “Search Posts”? Enlightenment may be there.