Take a look at the following sample I built.
Blur Test
I built what I described but added an adjustment layer and the Directional Blur Effect. I used keyframes to increase its value from 0 to 250 and then back to 0. See screen grab for reference. Hope this helps.

I played around a little more and I like the direction of the blur at 95%.
Stephen Smith
Utah Video Productions
Check out my Vimeo page