I’ve yet to have a problem with LaCie, after 4 HD’s a 52x CD burner and 16x (think that’s what it is, it’s fast anyhow) DVD burner.
Not. One. Single. Problem.
And that’s not counting edit suites I’ve worked where LaCie drives are common.
The last person I’d trust for comments on tech stuff are a) whiners, and b) people who’ve obviously never even used the product.
And if you believe there’s any brand of HD that won’t fail sometimes, you’re pretty darn gullible.