We backup to bare 500GB-1TB SATA drives. I have about 25 of these. Recently I lost a 500GB drive #3. It had projecst from 2007-2008….about 30 of them. The drive just clicked. It was still in warranty too.
I sent it to Seagate i365 for recovery. After 3 weeks of major head replacement etc, they are only able to recover about 100 GB of the 500 on the drive. Naturally smaller files have a better chance of recovery. They are one of the best in the business but hard drives are fickle machines when they go bad.
After we lost the drive I got duplicate drives for all the backups we had and copied them all to their own backup. I have one set in storage and one at the office. Right now that is about $3000 worth of drives.
Now I know that if I lose a 1TB drive I’m not getting much back. I think we are all going to have this issue as our backups get nearer and nearer to the 5 year warranty mark. I will get a new drive for the one that went bad but will probably lose a pile of project data.
I am considering a BluRay option to save all files except the huge media files and DVD builds etc as a more reliable longer term storage. We used to backup project files on DVD as well as Hard drive with all media. Stopped doing the DVD thing about 3 years ago. Too bad. They are rock solid. Now it might be BluRay…(so slow).
Right now, after our recent drive debacle, I am less and less trusting of the mechanical hard drive. And Since 1992 I have only experienced a bad drive two other times, from Avids to Media 100 to IMix Cube, including system drives. This one hurt.
Oh, and the 100 GB I might get back? Cost me $1400. In this case drives aren’t cheap!
Rich Rubasch
Tilt Media
Rich Rubasch
Tilt Media Inc.
Video Production and Post
Owner/President/Editor/Designer/Animator