I prefer AJA’s products. I’ve used the Blackmagic Decklink card, and it was fine since I was only doing SD with it, and since that’s what you’re doing it’ll be fine. The HD variants use a software based up / down / cross conversion whereas the AJA products do hardware based. I currently use an AJA IO (not HD) at home and it’s great for all my SD side work, and use a Kona 3 at the office. Their products work great, the software is fairly straightforward, and their tech support is unbeatable. I’ve never had to call Blackmagic for tech support, so I can’t comment on that.
You can find pretty good prices on an AJA IO, since so many people are jumping ship to HD. I got my IO used for $250 and it works like a champ. Just my own 2 cents on your workflow, digibeta is expensive but I would HIGHLY recommend you transferring to a good tape format as opposed to saving it on a hard drive. If you don’t, you’ll run into the issue that most P2 productions are running into, you have to keep it on a hard drive, and if you don’t front the cash for a RAID 5, you’re taking quite a gamble. A good alternative to digibeta would be DVCPRO 50. The decks are typically cheaper to rent, and the tapestock is cheaper too.
Richard Sanchez
North Hollywood, CA
“We are the facilitators of our own creative evolution.” – Bill Hicks