I guess it depends a lot on what you want to finish with.
Your super-16mm original will allow for finishing as HDTV /Hi Def video, via a digi transfer to 2K or another film resolution format, or as a standard definition master on NTSC (or PAL).
Widescreen never really made much of an impact in NTSC land, and there are few NTSC widescreen-capable monitors or TVs available. Most folks finish up with a letterboxed video stream for their widescreen – maybe one of the reasons HDTV has been particularly attractive in NTSC lands ?
So while DigiBeta isn’t of itself limiting you, your NTSC choice is a tricky one. You’d need to know whether your telecine was squeezed anamorphically (to allow you some kind of low-res path back to film in the end) or letterboxed.
And you’d want to know whether the NTSC tape is your final online medium, or whether you are going to go back with a cut negative for a 2K or HDTV scan, for a final master …
These things will influence your choice. Otherwise, as Jeremy points out, NTSC Digibeta uses 720×486 pixels, and if you want to widescreen this then 864×468 gives you the unsqueezed dimensions. But as Shane indicated, theres’ not a lot of widescreen NTSC support out there in the market, if the final delivery is to be an NTSC master …
Hope this helped more than it feels like it does!
BTW, what film stock(s) were you on, and how does the telecine look?