Thanks Walter,
I will admit, my response was a little knee-jerk. To be fair, I am not the primary user of the PC. I probably know more about PCs and PC troubleshooting than most PC users. I regularly set up museum installations on them, but I have never used one every day. Our editor who is the primary user and has gotten used to it and likes it. I am just the best at troubleshooting computers in our small studio so it usually comes to me to get it working again when something goes wrong, and things seem to go wrong with it more often than the macs in the office.
Also, I think some of our problems might be due to the manufacturer. We decided to go with a Pro-Max for our first PC under the assumption that they were designed specifically for video editing so we would have less problems. We have had a number of hardware problems with the machine as well as software, and I suspect some of it may be due to the machine not having enough internal ventilation.
We have had a lot of problems with the OS though, and strange sporadic problems with it refusing to connect to file share with the macs. (It works some days but not others. The support folks at pro-max never were able to figure that out).
At one point I believed that Adobe debugged their software better on Windows, and that the Windows side would be less buggy. In practice I haven’t found that to be the case, at least with AE and Premiere. There are just as many adobe bugs on Windows as there are on macs.
My thinking would be if you are in the market for an iMac, and not a mac pro, the extra money is worth it. The new iMacs are supposed to be great machines. Maybe I would think different if I used a PC every day.
Good luck with whatever your decision.
-Matt
Need a quick break from motion graphics?
Try my game Constellation at:
https://www.paperdragongames.com