You wrapped it up pretty wel there, Oliver. NO NLE is ideal for any editor/artist. There will always be things we love and hate about each and every one of them. Ideally, I’d take massive programming classes, write my own and quite gripin’. lol
As far as basic editing, my favorite is still Adcom’s NighSuite. Anybody here remeber those? RIP.
I still like many things about Stratosphere’s DVE and I still love Smoke’s tracker.
I like DS’s ability to offer trees or timelines and it’s compositing will spoil a bother quickly.
I love the price point and bang for the buck factor of FCP as well as it’s simple ability to grow with the editor/studio without the need to reinvent the wheel when upgrading.
I dig Vegas’ audio strengths and still laugh at Avid’s audio weaknesses.
I like Jaleo’s ability to extrude, bevel and light logos and text without having to go to AE. No, marquee is no answer. Just more egg on the face of Avid.
Notice I mention nothing in a positive sense about any Aviod product but DS, which again was purchased, not written by them. This really should stand out in their minds. It seems to me they should buy one of each NLE on the market, disect it, learn from it and grow their product(s). This, of course, is assuming they don’t have huge stock in Apple/FCP and at this point, I assume they do. I see no other explaination for letting their once annointed Media Composer take a side seat to FCP. If that was the plan, they should celebrate. If not, somone needs to lose their job because they are really bad at it.
There wasn’t a bigger Avid fan in the world than me just a few years ago and that was for many years. Now, I simply cannot bring myself to write them another check. I don’t just mean out of principal because they have their customers pay to beta test their struggling products now. I mean literally, I have no money now because I made the mistake of making payments on an Adrenaline. Trying to place the same clients behind this box when they were use to the stability of a real Avid proved to be fatal for my business. Now they literally have to be talked into coming my way “even though I have an Adrenaline” as they put it. I owe two more years at 1250 a month on a box that is worth less than 10k now. Thats pretty tough to swallow.
I don’t even pay for assurence now because the few times I have called I get the same response “hmm, well that otta work.” I agree. What we paid for really should work. It should have when we purchased it. It should have when you advertised it.
Avid, if not offering refunds, you at least owe an explaination.
