Apparently it was the deck. After the “Error 02” message continued to show on the AJ-HD1200A, even when put onto my other editor’s G5 (the 3rd system I’d checked), it became obvious. I returned it to the rental house, got a replacement, and everything seems to be fine so far, several tapes into capturing. The other clue was that the little green “720p” light had never shown on the first deck. No big deal except for the 8 hours of downtime and troubleshooting… alas, such is post.
I still think the 1200-FCP relationship is more touchy than when capturing DV or from other decks, but this is probably due to the fact that my footage is all run-and-gun, handheld style, from tape insert to eject. It’s a luxury if I can run bars and tone at the top of a tape. Capture-sensitivity is the price I pay.
And for anyone thinking otherwise, I still think the varicam-FCP-720HD “tapeless post” is by far the best way to go for documentaries. I’ve used film, DVX, Sony900 1080i, HDV, DVcam, you name it– the Varicam footage is gorgeous, the camera is superb, and I now have over a hundred hours of full res footage sitting on this little tower by my G5 (8 x 400gig drives). That’s my online.
Thanks for the previous advice about capturing.
doug