David Cherniack
Forum Replies Created
-
[Steve Connor] “[Michael Gissing] “I am sure Steve means that it is already on the clip just like Motion, Opacity etc. In the past you had to select a CC plugin and add it to the clip. Now it is just there.”
Thank you Michael that’s exactly what I meant”
Just so it’s clear. The Color Panel invokes an instance of the Lumetri effect in the Effects Panel where the effect is maskable and stackable, effectively creating as many secondaries as you want.
Not commented upon much, but looking like a great addition, are the Speedgrade scopes inside Premiere.
David
https://AllinOneFilms.com -
[Charlie Austin] “I’m seeing a therapist to try and get over it. lol”
Hmmmm. An excellent decision. Maybe there’s hope for you and Steve (and maybe even Lance lol). But the cure will be complete when there’s a screaming new Windows box standing beside your trashcan.3
David
https://AllinOneFilms.com -
[Charlie Austin] “hover scrub was intro’d a year after X came out, and skimming had been in iMovie since 2007. I’d be very surprised if there wasn’t some influence on that one. How about Search Bins? Not that it really matters… ;-)”
I didn’t know about skimming in iMovie in 2007 because I’ve never glanced at iMovie. But proto-skimming and search bins we had in edit* in the 90’s. Plus a lot of other innovative UI things that have yet to make it into any NLE. Who knows how much influence competitor innovations have on product development. Only the developers and they’re not telling. In Apple’s case, not even to their Mothers
David
https://AllinOneFilms.com -
[Steve Connor] “Maybe the actual functionality was, but the fact it’s at clip level is straight from FCPX”
I have no idea what you mean by “it’s at clip level”. Where else would it be? Like all effects, internal or external in Premiere..
I thinks you guys should get over what apparently is a a bit of a persecution complex. “If Apple had done ____ people would laugh at it but when Adobe does it everyone thinks it’s shit hot.” C’mon. X isn’t going to rule the world like 7 mostly did but it’s not going away and most sane people know that. Course if they added tracks….:)
David
https://AllinOneFilms.com -
[Charlie Austin] “Of course. Nothing about X has “inspired” Adobe at all.”
Well Charlie, I wouldn’t know, about “nothing” and I could never speak for Adobe but I see no evidence that the color panel is anything more than Lightroom inspired and with the amount of development work going back to version 5 of the Mercury engine, hover scrub was likely on the drawing boards 6 years ago.
David
https://AllinOneFilms.com -
[Steve Connor] “It’s certainly had a positive effect on PPro, look at “hover scrub” and the new clip level colour controls are obviously inspired by the Color Box in FCPX’s inspector.”
I believe Hover Scrub was in the works long before X and the Color Panel was inspired by the popularity of the color controls in Lightroom
David
https://AllinOneFilms.com -
[Scott Witthaus] “Problem is that it’s in Premiere…”
I’m sure there’ll be a 30 day free trial when they release it so the only obstacle would be ideological and surely no-one here is an NLE idealogue….
David
https://AllinOneFilms.com -
[Scott Witthaus] ” Let’s make it possible for news producers or political spots to completely eliminate context as a pesky barrier. Make them say whatever works best for you. Ugh.”
I do believe that’s possible to do with existing technology. Morph Cuts will only make it possible to do more seamlessly. But like doing same with cutaways what you’re talking about is within the provenance of integrity not of tools.
For those cases where content-adding cutaways are not available morph cuts is the greatest thing since…well…the Ginzu Knife (which was even greater than sliced cheese.)
Anyway, try it and be amazed.
David
https://AllinOneFilms.com -
[Lance Bachelder] “Crazy how they placed the new Lumetri color panel exactly where the Color panel is in FCPX – which I love by the way. Nice move Adobe.”
Not so crazy as we can assume that the color panel, like all panels in the Premiere Pro UI, will be moveable and undockable so it’s position will a matter of user preference.
David
https://AllinOneFilms.com -
An end to brand fetishism. Is that asking too much? OK, world peace then.
Anything really new and original that moves its field a quantum jump forward.
David
https://AllinOneFilms.com