[Simon Ubsdell] “If you really are doing ripple moves all the time, then maybe you need to be doing more thinking about what you’re doing and less random moving of stuff around?”
Hmmm. I don’t know what kind of editing you do. But the kind of editing I do involves continually cutting to get the length down as low as possible while retaining the message. This involves a lot of cutting words, cutting pauses, shortening gaps, heck even speeding up interviews when they are off camera. And, yes, more rarely rearranging order. But, all of these things involve ripple edits. Ripple edits are basically my bread and butter.
What I don’t do is a lot of trim tweaking. To this I would rephrase your original posit, “If you’re trimming a lot maybe you need to think more about setting your in point properly when you put the clip in.” ? Of course, I’m half joking here.
But let me ask you. Is it possible the difficulty of easily rearranging clips in other NLE’s actually discourages experimentation to get the best possible edit? While I don’t do it a lot, when I do it really makes an enormous difference.
Sometimes I think there is a disconnect between those editing news/documentary/web videos versus those editing scripted videos. Honestly I think they are in completely different worlds with completely different needs.
————————–
Brett Sherman
One Man Band (If it\’s video related I\’ll do it!)
I work for an institution that probably does not want to be associated with my babblings here.