I was thrown back into the Avid world for seven months last year to offline a Discovery Channel series. I’ll add a few “Avid does it better” items since we’re on the topic…
1) The Digitize Tool. One window contains everything: big flashing red button that easily tells you when you’re digitizing, buttons for track selection (how many times have I captured audio only in FCP because the track selection is hidden behind a tab?), the ability to name a clip WHILE it’s capturing, actual live timecode display during capture (very helpful when a deck is in another room), and live software audio meters during capture.
2) Zoom. ‘Nuff said on this one in previous posts. It’s the only Avid key I still reach for after 4+ years of FCP use (after 8 years on a Media Composer).
3) Digital Cut Tool- Avid’s “Edit to Tape.” This shows the playhead moving through the sequence during layback as well as live software audio meters and timecode display from the record deck.
So, my gripes are mostly I/O based (getting stuff in and out). FCP’s capture and output tools haven’t changed much since version 1.0, but a refresh could go a long way…
Despite my minor gripes FCP is still by far my tool of choice for actual cutting and effect work.
Cheers,
Bill