We were an FCP motion shop…
or a Motion FCP shop.
For us…
we NEED Creative cloud because as an agency all departments rely on the tools.
Premiere would just be there anyway…and it ran on hardware we have…but opens the door to be on any platform we want.
And for us it’s TON easier to find After Effects artists than Motion artists.
Now all that aside…
Adobe has done a bang up job making it pretty easy for FCP editors to use transition to PPro without missing a beat. No it’s not exact. but it’s really good.
Set your keyboard shortcuts and you’ll be pretty comfortable.
Never really have to think about whether footage I receive from anyone will work. It always does.
I’ve even brought over XML’s from old FCP projects so I can continue to use them in PPro when I need to.
Now let me also say….my PPro needs vary from short format offline an prep for After effects…
to 3-4 camera multicam mixed resolution HD/SD projects…that run about an hour.
PPro works great for us in these scenarios…but I may not push it as hard a other folks do.
The thing is…you can try it for free…and you’ll probably always have it around…as it’s in the cloud subscription anyway. Photoshop is a must have. So you really can’t lose.
hth…
Alex Udell
Editing, Motion Graphics, and Visual FX