Jeff,
Thanks for your thoughtful and generous reply. We all learned something from it.
One other non-ADR plan that may help people is in situation where you have multiple takes and there’s a problem with the “keeper” take.
Vocalign software, either stand alone or plugin can make a “keeper” out of a bad take. If the problem is just a small section of the “keeper”, you may be able to use a portion of the audio from another take. Vocalign will analyze the “keeper” and apply time compression and expansion to the target take to make it match the timing of the “keeper.” It works scarily well a lot of the time, but there are limitations.
I interviewed an LA post house (Doc Kane, I think) and he said Vocalign reduced their ADR by about 70%.
Regards,
Ty Ford
Want better production audio?: Ty Ford’s Audio Bootcamp Field Guide
Watch Ty play guitar