Johnny,
Good point, however, some people may need the extra functionality provided by Sony’s XDCAM Transfer software that is not provided in the Final Cut Log and Transfer plug-in.
For instance, I have found that my Shot Markers don’t show up in my video clips when I use Final Cut’s Log and Transfer feature. That’s why I personally need to use XDCAM Transfer.
Here are some other notes provided by Sony:
NOTE: XDCAM Transfer has the following advantages over Log and Transfer
Support both XDCAM EX & XDCAM Disc
Handles XDCAM EX and XDCAM Disc clips
mounting SxS & PD media at the same time
MXF export capability
Can write edited material back to Professional Disc in MXF files
Standalone browser/viewer
Browsing/viewing are possible without running Final Cut Pro
Other benefits
Full-screen playback
Cache functionThumbnail information available even after ejecting the media
Can create multiple sub clips by Mark In/Out
Log and Transfer has the advantage of working directly within the standard Log and Transfer interface within FCP