[Jamie Dannatt] “So from what you’ve mentioned, would you say that the big difference is mostly in the user experience, the user interface, or in the capabilities of the software?”
There is also the classic point about cost. Whereas you could easily get AE yourself, there probably is no damn way you’d buy a Quantel iQ/Pablo or a Flame because of the semi-insane prices of those.
I’ve used AE, Quantel iQ and Smoke/Flame 2012 and there really isn’t a huge performance gap between these. iQ is a great online tool, but not so great tool for just effects and compositing. Flame is really nice when it comes to media management and node based compositing and it’s fairly easy to learn if you know the basics. Smoke is goddamn terrible for editing but it has basically the same tools as Flame.