I found out what the problem was. In my Subdivision Surface object options, my Subdivision Editor was 5, while Subdivision Renderer was at 0, making it only show in the Render View. Thanks again for taking the time to answer me.
I made the Face out of a cube, which I then put into a Subdivision Surface to create soft edges. When I render it in the picture viewer, it seems like it turns of the subdivision layer, only rendering the cube.