[Mike Richmond]

I know this is an old thread, but I had the same problem. I shot with two HV30s and one XHA1 and then found that the ‘only’ difference in FC (in this case, the new version 7) was the field dominance. All three cameras were set as in the original post above. I captured using one of the HV30s for tapes from all three cameras. The HV30-recorded tapes captured as Upper field dominance, while the XHA1-recorded tape captured as “none” when captured by FC using the HV30.

Unlike the original post, I was able to get this fixed by capturing the XHA1-recorded tape in the HV30 using Capture Magic, creating an .m2t file. Then I used MPEG Streamclip to convert to ProRes 4:2:2 and followed the dialog box hints for progressive material. MPEG Streamclip doesn’t have a ‘none’ option for field dominance.

So now all three of my tapes are captured with Upper field dominance and multiclip in FC is happy.

MikeR