FWIW, some people *do* just throw stuff onto the FCPX timeline, ignoring the very detailed pre-logging process. And it works pretty great. I know that’s not the official paradigm, but a lot of what I get to work with is short, news-cutting type work with a very limited pool of shots, a setup that doesn’t benefit as much from the “pre-grooming” of the ingested material, and for that kind of thing, FCPX in trained hands is lightning-fast, the magnetic timeline really helps and the positioning tool is intuitive as well. A point in Adobe’s favor is, my premiere setup renders the same prores files a lot faster than FCPX seems to, and I can’t figure out why.
I’d def agree you should also check out Resolve. But I was in exactly the same boat as you were; I just stuck it out as Apple kept iterating FCPX and now it is quite mature and capable. I dabble in premiere but it feels like grandpa’s Buick to me. Every time I wanna add a transition or crop something and have to go thru Premiere sub-menus, I grimace and say: “oh, come ON!”.