[Jonathan Howells]

Hi Geoff,
Sounds like you’ve got your results, but another great tool is from Motionvfx, called mRotoAI
Check it out for next time

I use it in Motion5, and it works REALLY well

https://www.motionvfx.com/store,mrotoai,p3922.html

motionvfx.com

mRotoAI — Revolutionary AI-Powered Masking Tool for Final Cut Pro

Introducing mRotoAI, a game-changing plugin to effortlessly achieve masking, rotoscoping, and tracking with AI-powered precision. Redefine what's possible, focusing on your vision as artificial intelligence handles the tedious work. Streamline your creative process and embrace the future of video editing!

[Jonathan Howells]

Hey Ben

Fair enough, but we’ve done tests where we’ve build 2 projects – one in AE and one in Motion, and where AE can take 10-20 minutes to export it’s project, Motion takes 10-20 seconds.

Don’t get me wrong, AE is unavoidable, as the industry is built around it, and it’s had virtually no competition for so long. And we use it all the time, but Motion as well.

In my opinion, AE has some series memory management issue deep down. I don’t know what it is, but all of the freelance designers we work with who use AE, all find the export times strangely long for seemingly simple comps.

Just real world example of part of my frustration with AE. Slow exporting, not real time, etc.

[Jonathan Howells]

Thanks Ben. I’ll give that a good read!

[Jonathan Howells]

Hey Ben,

Indeed. I don’t really understand the math behind PreMultiplied vs Straight, but why there are 2 ways of doing alphas that are continually in conflict with each other in different software – that’s just silly.

And yes, while Motion seems to have mysterious omissions in it’s quite basic settings (such as being able to choose Premultipled vs Straight alphas) I do think that Motion’s outstanding animation capabilities give it the unique distinction of being the ‘best-application-that-no-one-has-heard-of’ (other than FCP editors, that kinda regard it as a novelty software).

I am a massive fan of Motion 5, and am constantly singing it’s praises, as often as I am criticising After Effects, which I think is abysmally slow at the most simple tasks, compared to Motion 5. Motion, as those who use it know, is virtually real time, and so fast to export, which AE struggles with. How do people meet deadlines using AE?! ; )

We really do use Motion 5 almost exclusively for professional broadcast and film motion graphics, for many of the top broadcasters and streaming channels, and most people would assume that work had been done in After Effects, but it’s all Motion 5. Most people truly have never heard of it. I explain to them that it’s Motion’s answer the the After Effects problem. ; )

After Effects just dominates so much, no one questions it, or asks if there are alternatives out there. Perhaps if there was a PC version, there would be more discovery of it’s brilliance.

I am on a personal mission to illuminate this broadcast graphics industry to the fact that AE is crap and Motion is actually better. I truly believe that.

[Jonathan Howells]

I seem to be having a conversation with myself here ; ) but I will now add more information.

Having spoken with an online editor, he has assured me that YES AVID can, like After Effects, be told how to interpret a clips alpha channel. This is the answer to my woes, because Motion 5 (annoyingly) seems to have no way to change its default of exporting alpha channels as PreMultiplied. No way to tell it to export Straight alphas (if I am wrong, please tell me).

And because AVID’s default is to treat alphas as Straight, I now I know I can tell online editors to direct AVID to re-interpret what we provide them (when with alphas from Motion 5) as PreMultiplied rather than Straight, and things will look correct – life will be good. I hope.

I hope this conversation with myself might be helpful so others!

Signing off

Jonathan

[Jonathan Howells]

Hi all, so since posting this question, I’ve done further research, and further testing.
I have now come to the conclusion that it’s all about Straight vs PreMultiplied alpha channels.

Having dropped a Motion 5 ProRes4444/alpha export into After Effects again, but this time investigating the “interpretation” of the alpha – sure enough, AE was interpreting the ProRes4444 from Motion as having a Straight alpha, but I have understood the Motion’s default is to export with PreMultiplied alphas.

So forcing AE to interpret as PreMultiplied, completely solves the issue – is displays correctly.

The more critical next test will be discussing AVID with editors and online editors I am in touch with, to confirm whether AVID can do the same ‘re-interpreting’ of alphas that After Effects can

AVID’s own documentation is frustratingly scarce and insufficient, and there is very little current information only – I did find one forum discussion where it was stated that since the 2018 version of AVID Media Composer, it CAN finally be told how to interpret alpha channels… but I’m not sure…

I hope this is true – stay tuned. But if anyone has more information on AVID’s ability in this regard, please let me know.