[Walter Soyka] “Owning tools doesn’t give me a warm fuzzy glow of security. What’s there to own? The “pliers” tool analogy doesn’t work with computers. My old CS3 installation discs won’t help me sleep at night in 2013.”
Here’s a fun “what if” that is actually real: imagine that Adobe introduces a disastrous bug into your NLE, making it literally impossible to do your work? What then? Download the update and hope you don’t trip over the bug? Download the update and hope they patch it quickly? Stay at your current version of the NLE but continue paying them a monthly rental?
(For the uninitiated: I’m referring to the spanned AVCHD clip bug that still hasn’t been fixed in Pr CS6)
Let’s look at those choices. The first two are just trouble waiting to happen. Specially if you make money with your NLE. Hopefully no professional would choose either of those. That leaves the third: stay at the present release. Well, great. You’re paying them money for something that you’ll never update until they fix the bug. Their excuse for going to the rental software is that they’re free to release new features on a regular basis. How’s that benefiting you during this “bug” problem? It’s not. And it’s costing you money.
What if they release new features that you really want, but still haven’t fixed the bug? What if it took them more than a year to fix the bug? What if they were never able to fix it (as is probably the case with the aforementioned CS6 bug)?
Paying for perpetual licenses gives you, the end user, far more freedom to pick and choose IF you want to pay for the upgrades.