Actually, Mr. Indian’s problem is a real problem, and I saw this EXACT problem the first time I had to use a Sony HDW-M2000/10 VTR (which does not have 2:3 pulldown native to the VTR).
My client, who was new to the time, rented a CineAlta, and shot in 24p. Thats right, they shot at 24, not 23.98, which is a choice on the camera (and useful if you are going to print back to film). Of course, they were not doing this, but were ignorant at the time about the difference between 23.98 and 24p (these manufacturers DO make it confusing). Unless you have some fancy assed frame rate converter, if you shoot in true 24 – you are SCREWED with conventional equipment. To video people, 24p means 23.98 – just like normal video is 29.97, not 30 frames per second (when you shoot in film, shooting at 30fps does not mean you can edit with this until a pulldown is done on the telecine).
Unless you are George Lucas, NEVER EVER EVER set a camera for 24 frames per second – always 23.98. Of course, with this said, I fully understand that many products say “24” when they mean 23.98. What is killing me these days, is all the companies that call HD-SDI, just SDI. Well, is it standard def SDI, Hi def SDI, or auto sensing for both ?
Don’t worry, however – as 2k and 4k become more popular, it will become even more confusing. And we thought that 44.1k and 48k digital audio was confusing – HA !
bob Zelin