Ron, eight days ago I had deep abdominal surgery via Da Vinci – and a human being.
The day after surgery, he stopped in my room, and I told him about this debate. Yes, he said, the machine can record everything that he does. Yes, it has a better memory than humans. Yes, some day, AI might do it all. “BUT” … He believes that the big problem will be “vision.” Every single human he has operated on, he said, was “a snowflake.” Each one is different. And the Da Vinci’s vision is not yet acute enough to interpret what it “sees,” since it cannot possibly have seen it before.
He was already in his scrubs, being called into the OR for his next patient, and I was on some very dreamy pain meds, so that is as far as our dialog went. I don’t understand enough to interpret it in any way. Just reporting what he said. Vision, and snowflakes.
I suspect that this is a “horses for courses” argument. Some surgeries – AI will be great. Some ASPECTS of almost all surgeries – yes.
Others – not for a very long time.